You get:
- all headlines pinned to position 1 (Google can’t optimize)
- no headlines pinned (weakest asset shows first)
- descriptions that repeat the same benefit
- headlines that don’t include the keyword
- no systematic way to identify weak assets
But RSA optimization is not set-and-forget.
It is a balance of control and machine learning.
- Pin your best, keyword-rich headline to position 1
- Leave 2-3 headlines unpinned for Google to test
- Replace any headline with low click-through potential
- Descriptions should offer distinct benefits, not repeats
Without RSA discipline, you leave performance on the table.
This framework forces AI to be an RSA specialist who optimizes systematically.
Assume the role of a Google Ads RSA specialist who knows that over-pinning kills performance. Your task is to analyze existing RSA assets and provide optimization recommendations. Generate: 1. HEADLINES TO PIN - Which headline to pin to position 1, 2, or 3 - Rationale for each (e.g., "Headline 1 contains the keyword, so pin to position 1") 2. HEADLINES TO LEAVE UNPINNED - Which headlines should never be pinned (let Google optimize) 3. DESCRIPTIONS: PIN VS. FLEXIBLE - Should descriptions be pinned? (Rarely — recommend leaving flexible) 4. WEAK HEADLINE WARNING - Which headline has low click-through potential and should be replaced - Why it's weak (too generic, no keyword, doesn't differentiate) 5. SUGGESTED NEW HEADLINE TO TEST - One new headline (30 characters max) INPUTS: Existing Headlines (list them): [HEADLINE 1, HEADLINE 2, HEADLINE 3... etc.] Existing Descriptions (list them): [DESCRIPTION 1, DESCRIPTION 2... etc.] Primary Keyword: [INSERT KEYWORD] Current CTR (if known): [INSERT % OR "UNKNOWN"] RULES: - Pin at most 1-2 headlines to position 1 — never pin all 3 - If a headline does not contain the keyword, recommend moving it to unpinned or replacing it - Descriptions should almost never be pinned (Google optimizes combinations better) - The weak headline warning must include a specific reason - The suggested new headline must be under 30 characters
- Review RSA assets monthly — Google’s algorithm needs fresh inputs.
- Pin your keyword-containing headline to position 1 for relevance.
- If CTR is below 1%, the weak headline warning is likely correct — replace it.
- Never pin descriptions unless you have a legal or brand reason (rare).
- Test the suggested new headline for 2 weeks before evaluating.
Existing Headlines: “Buy Office Chairs” / “Ergonomic Seating” / “Free Shipping” / “Shop Now” / “10-Year Warranty”
Existing Descriptions: “Ergonomic office chairs with free shipping. Shop our collection today.” / “10-year warranty on all chairs. Adjustable lumbar support included.”
Primary Keyword: “ergonomic office chair”
Current CTR: 0.7%
This framework improves outcomes by forcing:
- strategic pinning (1-2 headlines max)
- keyword-in-headline requirement
- weak headline identification
- description flexibility recommendation
- testable replacement suggestions
Great RSA optimization doesn’t control everything — it controls what matters and lets Google learn the rest.
Build Better AI Systems
Subscribe for advanced prompt engineering, AI marketing tools, Google Ads frameworks, and practical strategies for advertisers and business owners.